What’s a state institution to do?
Across the nation, college campuses have been working to respond to recent changes and proposed changes to the way international students, faculty and staff members are allowed to study, live and work in the U.S.
Public and private universities can respond differently as they are subject to different sets of constraints. As a state institution, Appalachian is subject not only to federal laws and regulations, but also to the General Statues of the State of North Carolina, and the policies of the University of North Carolina system. Find out more about that here.
There is, however, a lot that Appalachian can do, and is doing. Here’s what the university has been asked to do, and some information on what the university is doing to support international students, faculty and staff, as well as to provide general programmatic information to our students.
Here’s what Appalachian has been asked to do:
Since the first Executive Order was signed, Appalachian heard a variety of sentiments expressed by both supporters and opponents of the order, including specific requests to actively resist and actively endorse the content of the order.
On March 7, the Appalachian Student Government Association published on their Facebook page a document entitled, “Official Statement from the Howard/Dawson Administration of the Student Government Association in regards to the White House Executive Order.” This statement called upon the Board of Trustees, the Chancellor and the UNC General Administration to “declare Appalachian State University as a sanctuary campus immediately.”
On March 7, a group identifying as AppState Conservative Resistance published a petition on Change.org requesting “that the leadership of UNC system/Appalachian State University immediately and publicly deny” the Student Government Association request.
Also in March, faculty and other members of the Appalachian community presented a letter and petition to the Chancellor and Provost, asking the university to take the lead in protecting members of the university community from unfair intimidation, investigation and detention, as well as unfair prosecution.
What CAN Appalachian do?
As a state institution, a member of the University of North Carolina system, an accredited institution of higher education and an institution that receives federal funding Appalachian is subject to numerous rules and regulations. Here’s what we can do while remaining compliant:
Join with other colleges and universities across the country to show a unified voice in valuing and supporting immigrants and international students, faculty and staff.
On Feb. 3, Chancellor Everts joined more than 600 colleges and universities in signing a letter to Secretary of Homeland Security John F. Kelly expressing concern with President Trump’s Jan. 27, 2017 executive order.
On March 15, Chancellor Everts again joined hundreds of educational institutions across the country in a letter to President Trump expressing support for America’s “Dreamers,” a term named after the Development, Relief and Education for Alien Minors Act, a bill first introduced in congress in 2010, which would create a pathway to citizenship for undocumented children who grew up in the United States. The act failed to pass, but the term has lived on, as a way to describe children and young adults who were brought into the U.S. illegally as minors, and who have lived lives as Americans. These individuals are not documented, so they are not tracked, yet they attend colleges and universities across the country. The Obama Administration released a white paper and fact sheet on the economic value of America’s Dreamers in 2010. Read more about Dreamers and the DREAM Act here.
The Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act (FERPA) (20 U.S.C. § 1232g; 34 CFR Part 99) is a Federal law that protects the privacy of student education records. The law applies to all schools that receive funds under an applicable program of the U.S. Department of Education. The term "education record" is broadly defined and basically includes any university-maintained information about a student other than that which the university defines by policy as "directory information."Here’s where you can find out about FERPA information for Appalachian students.
It is important to note:
- There are exceptions under FERPA,that permit disclosure of education records. Exceptions include disclosures related to emergency health and safety concerns, and disclosures pursuant to a lawfully issued court order or subpoena.
You can read more about those here:
- Students may request their directory information not be published. Students can do this by contacting the Office of the Registrar at (828) 262-2050 or firstname.lastname@example.org.
- Appalachian does not list immigration status as directory information and, except for narrow exceptions related to specific federal reporting requirements, does not share immigration status. (Federal immigration regulations require Appalachian to update and maintain faculty, staff, and student records in the F, J, and H-1B categories.)
- Appalachian does include "permanent address" in its definition of directory information.
You can read the policy here:
- Appalachian does have a process for changing university policy.
You can read more about that here:
Make the safety of our university community members the utmost priority.
There are members of our community who are feeling fearful, and who both need and deserve the support of the institution that welcomed them to the United States, to Boone and to our campus.
The Chancellor and her cabinet and leadership are committed to exercising every available legal option to ensure the safety and well-being of all members of our community, and to provide each and every member of our campus community with a positive and fruitful learning environment. No one should feel afraid on our campus.
It is important to note that not all of these actions are taking place in the public eye. Staff and administrators conduct many of their duties in small groups and individual meetings or work sessions, particularly in cases in which it is necessary to provide individualized support to assist students, faculty and staff with specific situations. That said, there is quite a bit that is being done in larger groups and more public settings.
See What our campus is doing for more information:
See Resources for information and resources:
Assist with referrals to legal advice for students, faculty and staff.
While immigration law is a very specialized area, legal services are available to students, faculty and staff. Here are some places to start, get some general advice and when necessary, referrals and/or additional resources.
Students who have legal questions can consult with Appalachian’s Student Legal Clinic. It’s a free and confidential place to start with general questions, so if you need advice, make an appointment. While the legal clinic attorney can’t advise in all matters, she can provide general advice, and when necessary make referrals and direct students to additional resources.
For faculty and staff, the university’s Employee Assistance Program offers legal referrals and resources via ComPsych. Attorneys are on call for a free, 30-minute consultation, and if you require representation, you can receive a 25 percent reduction off their customary legal fees.
Additional information about legal resources can be found here:
Provide alternatives to in-class learning for students who are afraid to attend class.
Appalachian has many ways to assist students who are facing challenges that are impeding academic success. These include everything from technology support to social and emotional support, and are typically highly customized to meet the needs of the student. The bottom line, however, is that no one should feel afraid to attend class. If this is the case, then staff and faculty will work together to solve the underlying problem. The Dean of Students office is the place to begin, if you are a student or if you know a student who needs help.
Put in place measures to reduce hostilities on campus.
This is a key issue for any campus, and at Appalachian many resources are being directed toward improving dialogue, so we can have conversations that are solving issues of hostile communications, and we get more comfortable as a campus talking about difficult topics, and creating solutions together. Notably, this is work that is never done and requires diligence. We have an institutional commitment and plenty of expertise on our campus, so we all need to get involved, be willing to make mistakes, learn from them and keep working together.
To learn about initiatives underway, see “What our campus is doing.”
Honor confidentiality and offer emotional support.
FERPA (see Protect privacy above) also affords additional privacy protection for student educational records and most employment-related information in a personnel file is confidential as well, although there are exceptions to this, with which you can familiarize yourself here.
Learn more about more on and off-campus resources here:
Enhance the levels of counseling and wellness to be sure all members of our community are adequately served.
Student health and safety is a top priority at Appalachian. For students to progress academically, they must be well and safe. Wellness resources for students, faculty and staff are continually reviewed and evaluated for areas of additional growth and improvement.
The good news is, much recent progress has been made in terms of providing wellness and counseling resources, particularly for students. For students, the Counseling and Psychological Services center the Office of Wellness and Prevention Services and Student Health Services offer support and assistance for mental and physical health.
Create opportunities for additional education and discussion in a public setting.
This is where institutions of higher education excel, and can perhaps do the most to create, develop and continue constructive and thoughtful dialogue.
On March 29, nearly 150 students, faculty and staff turned out for an information session with Robert Lamb, associate attorney with Hatch Rockers Immigration in Asheville. Our campus possesses a tremendous amount of expertise in the areas of politics, law and international affairs, and there are resources to host and publicize speakers on our campus as well as panel discussions with members of our campus community.
Such efforts have and will continue to receive support from the Office of the Chancellor, Academic Affairs, Student Affairs, the Office of International Education and Development and other divisions and departments on campus.
What CAN’T Appalachian do?
Violate Federal or state laws.
Become a sanctuary campus.
To be clear, this does not mean Appalachian does not believe in supporting our international and immigrant students, faculty and staff. The university provides and will continue to provide support and assistance to these individuals, who enhance our campus daily with their presence, their cultures and their knowledge. Like every college in the country, we expect to work harder than ever before to attract and retain international student, faculty and staff talent.
The term “sanctuary campus” is not only highly politicized, it also has no legal or even widely agreed-upon definition or criteria. To be sure, the concept is an extension of the concept for sanctuary cities, but that term also has no legal definition and is not well defined societally.
There is an excellent information overview about this topic by Dan Berger and Stephen Yale-Loehr on the website for Miller Mayer, LLC a law firm based in Ithaca, New York. Here is one key excerpt:
“There has never been large-scale immigration enforcement on U.S. campuses. There have been individual actions. Therefore, it is not clear what form such action might take, and what kind of court challenges would be successful. It is not even clear what the definition of “campus” would be if a sanctuary is declared, since many institutions hold property outside of the main set of academic buildings. The American Council on Education (ACE) and other organizations are studying these issues, and deeper analysis will be forthcoming.”
The spirit of the sanctuary campus - to provide support for members of the university community when they need it - is keenly understood, however. Appalachian is committed to doing this in every way allowable by law.