| How
Small of a World is it, After all?
Steven J. Hageman
February, 1997
"I met a German girl in
England,
who was going to school in France.
she said we danced in Mississippi
at an Alpha-Kappa dance.
(Charles Edward Anderson Berry)
Here is a small world story
for you.... In 1994, while I was a postdoc at the University of
Adelaide
in South Australia, I lived in university postgraduate housing.
There
I met another American, Mike from Iowa (myself originally from
Missouri).
One evening, Mike and I were sitting in a pub in North Adelaide
discussing
life, the universe, etc., when it came out in the course of
conversation
that Mike had been a national park ranger in the Apostle Islands for a
season. The Apostles are a rather small group of islands located
in southern Lake Superior, which are accessible only by boat.
Mike
and I were pleased with the coincidence that I had also visited the
Apostle
Islands. I had camped in a remote site on the far side of the
main
island with a group of about 20 friends (actually a honey moon party
for
a couple of friends). For some reason, neither Mike or I could
remember
exactly when each of us had been to the Apostle Islands. Then I
remembered
that it was during the time of the coup in the USSR (August
1991).
I told Mike that I knew this because one night on the island a park
ranger
had come into our camp by boat to check on us and had asked us if we
had
any news about the coup. The ranger had a small radio and was
receiving
local news broadcasts, but did not know any details. Our party
had
been isolated for several days, so the news of the events came as quite
a surprise to us, and provided for an evening of speculation as to the
world's future. Three years later, in a pub on the other side of
the world, Mike took a sip of his Tooey's Old, smiled and said, "That
park
ranger was me."
Introduction
Everyone can share a small
world story
of their own. We have all met someone unexpected in an unlikely
place.
The improbability of the event becomes almost magical. It may be
something as simple as encountering an acquaintance from home some
place
in a large city miles from home. Other small-world stories are so
complex and complicated that the mere telling of the story makes the
coincidence
seem incomprehensible. The improbability of these events
occurring
makes the encounter become almost mystical. The same is true when
you meet someone for the first time and you find that you share a
common
friend, or have had a similar life experience as you (same fraternity
or
took the same vacation). After all, "... what are the odds?"
I have found, however, that
virtually
everyone has an "incomparable" small-world story. This fact
raises
the question of, "Just how unlikely (or likely) are these events,
really?".
Although odds and probabilities can not be applied directly, I
will
argue that, not only are such encounters not that rare, but that in
fact
they are virtually inevitable. The amazing event is not so much
that
small world stories happen at all, but that "near small world
encounters"
undoubtedly happen a rather frequently and most go unnoticed. For
example, it is quite possible that Mike and I could have known each
other
for a full year in South Australia and never have gotten around to
talking
about the Apostle Islands, for I am certain that we did not exhaust our
topics for conversation.
The Set Up
Growing up in a small,
rural northwest
Missouri town, my perspective of the world was all relative to a single
reference point: Home. The more I learned about the outside world
through magazines, television and the movies, the bigger my perspective
of the world became. Every new place I learned about expanded my
perceived size of the world. I can remember clearly when I was
eight
years old and my family was on a short vacation. We were shopping
in a book store in St. Louis, Missouri (some 300 miles from reference
point
Home), when my father recognized a acquaintance of his from work, who
also
happened to be browsing in the same book store. They made the
obligatory
"small world" joke and went on about their business. This event,
however, boggled my young mind. What were the chances of our
family,
meeting another family, from the same small town, in the same
bookstore,
in a huge city, clear across the state?
My second small world
encounter came
when I was twelve years old, on another family vacation. We were
staying in an old fashioned motel (single story stucco units with a
grass
courtyard and no pool) in Durango, Colorado. My father started
talking
to a young man in the steel lawn chair next to him on the grassy
courtyard
and it turned out that this man lived in a small town near my cousin in
Emporia, Kansas. The man knew my cousin casually from their using
the same live stock sales barn. Again, my small mind
whirled.
What were the chances, that this stranger passing through Colorado
would
know my cousin in Kansas?
The following are a few
more examples
of first hand small world stories.
- My Scottish colleague, Robert Hamilton
Bruce, with whom I
shared an office in Adelaide, worked for years in an animal laboratory
in Johannesburg, South Africa. When they were in Johannesburg a
close
friend of his wife's in Johannesburg moved away, returning to the
Netherlands,
where she grew up. Several months later Robert and his wife were
in London on holiday, where they uncharacteristically went to see a
first
release movie at the theater (Jaws). Minutes later her Dutch
friend
walked into the theater and sat next to them. Each assumed the
other
was at home (South Africa and Netherlands, respectively).
- Debbie, a friend of mine from graduate
school days at Urbana,
spent two years working in Madrid, Spain. Her sister from North
Dakota
visited her in Madrid and they spent one afternoon on a tour of a
classic
cathedral. When they met their small group for the tour, their
cousin
and her husband were there waiting for the same tour. Debbie's
cousin
lives in New Zealand and was on her honeymoon in Spain. Neither
knew
the other was in Madrid.
- Patty, an American from St. Louis who I met
in Adelaide,
met a woman in her physiotherapy class in Adelaide. Six months
later
Patty was touring in northern Scotland and unexpectedly met her
Australian
friend in a very small, remote stone church.
- When I was living in Adelaide, South
Australia I took a trip
to Cairns on the other side of the continent in far north Queensland
(Great
Barrier Reef area). I took a tourist train 30 miles inland, up a
mountain to a small touristic village in the rain forest. I
walked
through the small town and went into a crowded restaurant for
lunch.
I had to walk back through two rooms and onto the back porch to find a
seat. I sat in the only open table, which was next to a Canadian
couple who I knew from my housing complex in Adelaide. Neither of
us knew the other had even planed a trip to Cairns.
- My friend Rob was driving from Illinois to
Florida with his
wife one summer. On the interstate bypass around Atlanta they
passed
Dave, a friend of ours who was also driving to Florida. They
waved
as they went by.
- One day in Adelaide I was walking down the
sidewalk on campus
when a woman passed the other direction. I thought to myself, "My
gosh that woman looked like Peg Rees". Peg was my Optical
Mineralogy
teaching assistant at the University of Kansas some twelve years
previous
and whom I hadn't seen since. Two days later I received our
Departmental
newsletter that said we should welcome our visiting scholar, Margaret
Rees.
- Add your own
to the list.
Analyzing the Components of Mystique
The reason that small world
stories
are so attractive is that the apparent odds of the event occurring are
astronomical; approaching supernatural. The fact that everyone
has
an 'unbelievable' small world story or two demonstrates that the odds
are
clearly not astronomical. In order to resolve this paradox we
must
look at what the probability (odds) of an event occurring actually are.
If, for example, the next time
you
are to get on an air plane, if you were to ask, "what are the odds that
the person who has been assigned the seat next to me will be my 5th
grade
gym coach," the odds would indeed astronomical (though slightly higher
if you were flying out of your hometown than Caracas). However,
if
you were to ask, what are the odds that in the next several years I
will
cross paths with someone (anyone) unexpectedly, somewhere (anywhere),
sometime
(anytime), the probability becomes much, much greater. This
is the difference between the probability of single event happening or
the probability of any one of many events happening. The magic is
that when one of the many possible events does occur, we perceive it as
the odds of that single event occurring independent of all others.
There are a number of reasons
(factors)
why people grossly underestimate the likelihood of having a chance
encounter.
I will attempt to demonstrate the reasons why the actually probability
of a chance encounter are actually much greater than people's general
conceptions
of the probability once the event happens. I will do this by
analyzing
the characteristics of true "small world stories" of my own and of
those
told to me, first hand, by close friends.
Factor-1: You have more friends than you
can "ever
know."
(you gregarious soul, you!)
People, by in large,
underestimate
the total number of people that they know or have ever known over their
lifetime. When I put this in a form of a question to friends, a
common
reply is that their total number of acquaintances is in the hundreds or
low thousands. This may be an accurate figure for some one who
has
lived a sedentary life in a very small community, but for most people
in
the western world these days, I believe that the actual number of
life-time
acquaintances is in the high-tens to low-hundreds of thousands.
Reflect on you own
experiences.
Think of all of your past and present acquaintances. Your close
friends,
family members and work associates are likely to come to mind
first.
However, think of all of the people you ever knew at school, on sports
teams, at social clubs, and all the jobs you ever worked. Now,
think
of all the people who are friends of your friends and of your friend's
family members who you may have met once. Think of all of your
parents
friend's friends and your bothers' or sisters' friends. How about
the children of your parents' friends or the old girlfriends of your
brother's
friends? Now include people you have never even associated with,
but that you would recognize if placed in a position to do so, such a
members
of associated social clubs from nearby towns you met at district
meetings,
or semi-irregular customers at work. This may also include the
waitress
at your favorite coffee shop to the teller at the mini-mart down the
street
(both today and if you would recognize the one from a decade
ago).
Now include all the people you have ever met while traveling such as at
conferences or conventions or on vacation.
If you sum all of these people
up
over a life time, I believe you will find that the subset of the human
race that would be in a position to recognize and know you in an
unexpected
chance encounter is much larger than you would expect. The fact
that
you are not able to consciously compile this list at a single moment in
time demonstrates that you have the potential to recall many more
individual
people than you realize. This difference between your perceived
subset
of the human race you think you know (maybe 1,000-5,000 names if asked
for an immediate accounting) and the real subset of the human race you
know (likely 75,000 - 150,000), contributes significantly to the
apparent
astronomical odds of chance encounters resulting in small world stores.
Factor-2: Eliminate all those unfortunates
who will never know you
The astute fifth grade math
student
will note that proportional difference between perceived number of life
time acquaintance and the real number of life time acquaintances is
minimal
when compared to the worlds population of ~6,000,000,000 people.
This is true, but, the total number of people that one individual is
ever
likely to come into contact with is much smaller. There is only a
subset of the world's population that we are physically ever likely to
cross paths with (and the rest you will not). For example, with
the
St. Louis bookstore story, you could be pretty sure that the vast
majority
of the population of China and India (2.0 billion people) were not
going
to be in St. Louis that afternoon. If you consider that our
family
of four had a total acquaintance base of 200,000 and limited the subset
of potential book shoppers to just U.S. citizens, then the odds that we
would meet someone in the book shop we knew, the odds are down to
around
one in one thousand. Another way to look at this is that if a
person
spent their entire life in the United States and conservatively knew
25,000
people over their life, they would have known 1 in every 10,000
Americans.
Obviously our acquaintances
are not
randomly distributed (geographically) across the United States, nor are
they equally likely to be book shoppers, but that is where the next
misconceived
perception of likelihood of small world stories comes in.
Factor-3: People with similar life-styles have
similar
habits
and ...
Factor-4: have similar lists of acquaintances.
People with common origins
and interests
often have common life experiences. For example, many of the
people
I attended high school with in a small rural town in northwest Missouri
(pop. 10,000), are now professionals within 150 miles from home in the
Kansas City areas (pop. 1.5 million). I have heard a number of
stories
from friends who haven't seen each other since the day we graduated
from
high school, only to run into them in a video store in some suburb of
Kansas
City. Given then circumstances outlined above, over time, such
encounters
are almost inevitable.
As a geologist, I have met
many other
geologists in my day. Although people obviously have varied
interests,
there are many traits that tend to draw people into certain fields of
work.
These provide for a larger list of potential shared activities and a
decrease
in a certain number of things that they are likely to do.
For
example, in much later discussion with Mike, the
Iowegian-geologist-park-ranger,
he and I discovered that several years before, we had both visited some
of the same very small and remote villages in central Norway (but not
on
the same day).
Artists know artists, bookkeepers know
bookkeepers, cardiologists
know cardiologists, ... zoologists know zoologists. In addition,
people are much more finely tuned to (aware of) their own
interests.
As a necessity people are selective as to what they perceive, letting
the
rest of the overload of daily stimuli pass them by. A new car
owner
"sees more" models of his or her new car on the highway than other
drivers.
Pregnant couples typically perceive half the population to be pregnant
with them. Cat lovers see and talk cats. Academics
gravitate
towards bookstores. You notice the name of your alma matter on a
sweatshirt, etcetera, etcetera, etcetera. In other words your
interests
not only draws you together with people you are more likely to have a
connection
with, but it is also more likely that the connection will be recognized.
Factor-5. The last place I expected to
meet you:
...
can be the real reason you found each other
Magnets.--Some
places are much
more visited than others. The odds of meeting people at these
high
traffic "magnets" are greatly increased. Paris is a gateway to
Europe.
Most people who have spent any time traveling in Europe have at least
passed
through Paris. Some 10,000 Americans are actually residents of
the
city at any one time, and the number of American tourists on the
streets
of Paris during the summer must be staggering. In fact, I would
venture
that if you set up shop at the base of the Eiffel tower during peak
season
and made an active effort to identify people you know, you would
undoubtedly
find someone within a week.
Two real quick Paris
stories.
My friend Rob who was in graduate school in Urbana with me was walking
the streets of Paris one afternoon after a conference. He heard
his
name called and turned to see a woman who was the girl friend of
another
graduate student in our department at Illinois. Rob had only met
her a couple of times at parties and certainly wouldn't have spent
precious
Paris time looking for her. Nevertheless, she recognized Rob in a
crowd in a distant land and called him over.
Jay, a mutual friend of Rob
and mine,
lived in Paris some years later as a postdoc. One day while
eating
lunch in a small cafe on a back street of Paris, Jay recognized a woman
he knew from high school who walked past outside. Jay got up,
rushed
out, jumped in front of her on the sidewalk, and then realized that he
couldn't remember her name. Fortunately for him, Jay is a very
memorable
character in his own right and she remembered him. This
illustrates
that the mind can store acquaintances so deep in the memory that they
can
be recognized as acquaintances, even if they can't be identified by
name.
Paris is just one example of a
magnet
that draws large numbers of people to it. Any popular place, such
as the Grand Canyon or Statue of Liberty, or a festival such as the
Olympics‘
or a major city summer festival will unknowingly draw your
acquaintances
from all over. When I was in high school we would attend big rock
concerts in Kansas City, some 125 miles away and we were always
"amazed"
that we would see people we knew from home. Same with big sports
events, theme parks, casinos, and minor tourist traps. For
example,
I have been to the Nelson-Atkins Art Gallery (magnet) in Kansas City
only
twice in the past ten years. Both times I saw Father Tom, a
Catholic
priest who I knew from mutual friends in college. I don't even
know
where he lives, but I'm sure he doesn't work at the museum.
Isolation.--The
opposite of
a magnet is a remote place where there are very few people. In
such
a place it is inevitable that any two individuals will "encounter" each
other whether they know each other or not. In big magnets, such
as
Paris, it is very possible that two acquaintances could eat at the same
crowded restaurant at the same time and never recognize each other in
the
masses. If they were the only two people on top of a remote
mountain
at the same time, they would be guaranteed to encounter each other.
There are two types of
isolation.
In physical isolation the place is remote. For example, on New
Year's
day one year I was hiking by myself on a trail on the Blue Ridge
Parkway
in the mountains of North Carolina. It was a short trail down to
a waterfall and back (no loop). The only people that I saw on the trail
all afternoon happened to be a couple that I had known in Urbana, but
who
had moved to North Carolina several years ago. I didn't know them
very well, but he had lived with friends of mine and she was a close
friend
of another friend of mine from different circles. The odds of us
meeting on a trail in North Carolina were unexpected, but once we were
all on the trail, the fact that we would meet was inevitable, as we
were
the only humans present for miles on a path that must meet coming and
going.
Similar "remote" scenarios can be
speculated upon
for the only two early risers in a park for an early morning run or two
night owls in an empty late night coffee shop. Remember that
successfully
making the encounter is "half" the work in a small world story.
A second type of isolation is
cultural.
For example, my friend Basim was born in Basrah, Iraq. We shared
an office in the geology department in Adelaide, South Australia.
Basim had only been in Adelaide a few weeks when a new friend of his
told
him that he knew an Iraqi woman working at the local hospital.
Basim
called this woman and it turned out that she was also from Basrah (a
city
of 3-million), and she knew his family (she remembered his parents as
proficient
ballroom dancers at the club on weekends when she was little). In
addition, she turned out to be the cousin of one of Basim's childhood
friends.
She informed Basim that his friend was now living in Perth,
Australia.
The last Basim knew, his friend was living in India, and he had lost
track
of him years ago. Of course Basim called his old friend in Perth
and some months later they actually got together. Later,
Basim
was attending a geology conference when a stranger came up to him and
told
him that he had a colleague who had just started work in Sydney who was
Iraqi. He gave Basim the man's name and it was a person with whom
Basim had attended graduate school with in Baghdad. Again, Basim
had lost track of him years ago, but they got in contact by phone.
Although it is remarkable that
Basim
knew these people, I would argue that it was virtually inevitable that
these people would have learned about each other's existence.
There
just are not that many Iraqis living in Australia, so when a new one
does
arrive, the "word" gets around quickly. How long do you think it
would take for two people from Cleveland to find each other if they
were
both living in Ulaanbaatar, Mongolia? I would also note that
Basim
is a very motivated individual. He is the type to embark to, and
succeed in new and unknown lands. His chosen friends are of the
same
temper.
Factor-6: The next level: Expanding
spheres of multiple connections
Most of the small world
examples I
have given so far have been "Type-1" encounters, where one individual
meets
a second individual who they already know somewhere unexpectedly.
The probability of such encounters has to do with the total number of
people
each of these know, and the common tie (draw) of the place where they
meet.
A second type of small world
encounter
(Type-2) is when two strangers meet for the first time and discover
that
they both have a common acquaintance. Sometimes the remoteness of
the situation, the connecting of two worlds through a common thread not
physically present at the time, makes this type of encounter even more
mystical. This mystique can even be enhanced when two people have
known each other many years, only to find out that they have common
acquaintance
from times past. Note however, that when more people are
introduced
into the equation, there are more total acquaintances to potentially
have
in common. In addition, the effect is not increased additatively, but
rather
geometrically. Meaning that each of your acquaintances
potentially
has just as many acquaintances and each of them has just as many.
Say you know a modest 10,000 people: any one of them is your friend
Joe,
but each of those 10,000 knows a modest 10,000. That means that
the
total potential pool of people known by your all of your friends is 100
million. This means two things: first, many of your friends
already
share common friends; and secondly, total pool of people known by your
friends is much larger than you think. Thus the odds of having a
second order (Type-2 small world encounter) are actually much greater
than
a Type-1.
Additional levels can be
added.
For example, a Type-3 encounter occurs when two people find that they
share
some place or experience. For example both grew up in the same
town,
or belong to the same club, or took the same vacation. It is
almost
impossible to calculate the odds for Type-3 encounters because you are
drawing upon the totality of your life experience. Back to the
Paris
example, once the fact is established that two people have been to
Paris
independently, it would be a greater small world story if neither of
them
had visited the Eiffel tower than if both had.
Fourth type of encounter is
based
on any combination of Types 1, 2 or 3 into a single event.
Sometimes the complexity of telling a Type-4 small world encounter
generates
the mystique and improbability of the event itself. For
example:
In 1957 my father owned a contemporary jewelry store in Lawrence,
Kansas.
He purchased some pseudo-Scandinavian wire chairs for the shop. Ten
years
later he moved to Maryville, Missouri, across the street from the man
who
owned the small factory that manufactured the chairs. Years later
my brother married a local woman whose father had worked in the factory
welding the chairs some thirty years previously. It is a paradox
that these Type-4 evens seem all the more improbable, because they are
actually the sum total of all of our life events crossing the sum total
of other people' life events. In addition many of these events
are
directly correlated, that is, my brother met his wife because her
family
lived in the town where the chairs were made. People know people
in the place where they live (if they hadn't lived there it is much
less
likely they would have known them, therefore two-factors actually
combine
to one).
This can be illustrated
somewhat in
the following examples: Thomas Stoppard's play "Six Degrees of
Separation"
is based on the premise that every individual is connected to every
other
individual on the planet through a maximum of six other common friends
or acquaintances. That is, if I met stranger named Joe
Bloe,
one of my friend's friend's friend would know one of his friend's,
friend's,
friends. A spoof of this principle is played out (and
"convincingly"
demonstrated) in the popular World Wide Web sites: Six Degrees of Kevin
Bacon, The Oracle of
Kevin
Bacon, and The
Kevin Bacon Game. In these computer data sets, you can type
the
name of any actor who has ever played in a movie in Hollywood and the
computer
(or now ANY One The
Associate Degrees of Kevin Bacon) and the program will connect that
actor with Kevin Bacon within a few shared actor/movie roles. For
example if you type "Elvis Presley" the sequence would return:
- Presley, Elvis was in King Creole (1958)
with Matthau, Walter
- Matthau, Walter was in JFK (1991) with
Bacon, Kevin
The fact that Kevin Bacon's
limited (though
highly respectable) acting career can be connected to every actor who
ever
made a movie in Hollywood within a small number of steps, is a small
demonstration
of how rapidly the list of potentially common acquaintances expands
when
you open the list to higher levels (friends friends).
The ability to accommodate and
connect
every actor who ever played a role in a Hollywood movie within four
steps
is easily demonstrated with this simple model. If Kevin Bacon was
in a total of 10 movies with 10 different actors in each movie, that is
a modest 100 people he has ever worked with (Step 1). If those
100
actors were in an average of ten movies with an average cast of 10
actors,
that is 10,000 potential slots (Step 2). If those 10,000 were in
ten movies with ten actors, that is one million potential slots (Step
3).
Finally, if carried to its conclusion at the fourth degree, Kevin Bacon
could possibly be connected to 100,000,000 potential actors, or nearly
40% of the American population. So, as you can see the really
amazing
part is that anyone would bother to compile the comprehensive data set
of Hollywood casting records over the past century; not that Kevin has
mystical connections to the medium.
So, if you do the math on six degrees of
separation with
each person knowing a modest 10,000 other humans, the total of
1. 10,000
2. 100,000,000
3. 1,000,000,000,000
4. 10,000,000,000,000,000
5. 100,000,000,000,000,000,000
6. 1,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000
The sixth degree is 200 quadrillion times the
current population
of the world.
Nobody is that much of a recluse.
An example, a friend of
mine, Denise,
had known a friend in graduate school for some time. They knew
each
other long enough to get to know each other's family histories.
It
turned out that Denise's grandmother and this woman's grandmother had
both
grown up in the same small town in Wisconsin. Neither of their
families
live there now, nor had either of Denise or her friend visited
there.
Denise's grandmother is dead, but her friends grandmother said that
although
she was not close friends with Denise's grandmother, she distinctly
remember
the her and their family.
There is definitely something
mystical
about acquaintances, encounters and friendships skipping forgotten
generations,
and reuniting along the time-line. However, if one acknowledges
that
we are up to three degrees of separation (each woman to their
grandparent
and connection of grandparents), we see that the numbers of potential
contacts
rises quickly. The real testimony here arises from the fact that
the two people recognized the connection in the first place. Do
you
know the childhood hometown of the twenty grand parents of your five
closest
friend's? What small world stories are you missing out on?
The seeming improbability of
second
or third order small world stories may even cause the mind to deny the
reality of the situation. For example the connection:
Paul -friend of - Rob - son of - Mother
- maried
to - Stepfather Brewer - father of - Dolly - missing friend of - Paul
When we were fifth grade a family moved to
town that was
sort of like the Brady Bunch. Mr. Brewer had two daughters from a
first marriage. Later he married a woman and adopted her three
boys,
from previous marriage. The kids were all about my age and they
were
quite popular until their parents got divorced and they all moved away
at the end of eighth grade. One of the girls, Dolly, sometimes
hung
out with a group of my friends, which included a guy named Paul (we
were
all 13 yrs old). Years later, when we were in college, Paul was
friends
with a guy named Rob who had grown up in a small town nearby.
Paul
had met Rob's mother, knew she had been divorced when Rob was in high
school,
and knew that she had been remarried. Paul had known Rob for many
years before they all happened to be in Kansas City and were invited
over
to Rob's mother's and stepfather's place for dinner. Apparently
no
one had bothered to ever tell Paul that Rob's mother had married Mr.
Brewer
and that his daughter Dolly would be joining them for dinner.
Poor
Paul sat through dinner with this woman asking him strange questions
about
his hometown and distant acquaintances that Paul himself hadn't thought
of in years. Paul assumed that she had gone to college there, but
that he had never met her. Three quarters the way through dinner
Paul had an Epiphany, pointed at the woman, and loudly declared with
genuine
joy and surprise, "YOU'RE DOLLY BREWER!" Which of course, amused
all present to no end.
The point of this story is
that the
idea of connecting Dolly Brewer as the stepsister of his close friend
Rob,
was such a far stretch, that even under conditions presented to him,
his
mind refused to make the connection. I invite you to work out a
scenario
for yourself of two individuals you have known and imagine your
surprise
to see two distant worlds suddenly connected. However, I would
remind
you that half of all the people you know will get divorced and in the
rural
country of northwest Missouri (or any other socio-, cultural-,
professional-group)
the odds that they will remarry someone else you know are actually
fairly
high.
I met an American woman in
Ireland,
Who was living in New Zealand,
She said I met her husband in Hawaii,
at an Evolution meeting.
(Steve Hageman, 1992)
Well, just as I said.
When I was in Ireland on a paleontology field trip, I met a colleague
who
grew up in Connecticut, but is now living in New Zealand with her Kiwi
husband. The second day on the trip I wore a T-shirt from a
Hawaiian
Evolution meeting I had attended the previous year. She
immediately
recognized the conference logo and said that her husband, an
evolutionary
biologist, had attended the same meeting. She and I discussed the
conference and it's affiliated field trips and we surmised that her
husband
and I must have been in the same group of about 20 people who hiked in
to watch some active lava flows. Two years later, I met her
husband
at a meeting in Melbourne and confirmed that he and I had been on the
same
field trip in Hawaii. But ... that is not the end of the
coincidence.
When I returned from Ireland I started teaching in Boone, North
Carolina.
One day I was talking with a colleague of mine there about the Hawaiian
volcanoes and I said that it was such a great experience, except for
the
National Park Ranger who "led" the tour, who was a useless yahoo.
The worst part was that the park ranger was a geology Ph.D. student, so
you would have thought he would have had even more to offer a volcano
field
trip. My friend in Boone proceeded to describe the physical
characteristics
and mannerisms of this lame park ranger, and confirmed that he had been
her field assistant in Alaska for a season (one to forget).
Two points come from this
encounter
(one field trip with three people, two of which are connected to two
other
from difference places, both of whom connect with me at even different
places). Cosmic! However, I can't even calculate the
number of degrees of separation here (how many total people all six of
us know and all of the places that all six of us have ever been).
Plus, and this is a big one, we are all geologists/evolutionary
biologists,
which greatly limits the pool of potential people and greatly increased
the likelihood that we would be doing the same things (conferences and
volcanoes). Nevertheless, it's still a story worth telling.
But that's not the weird part ...
Growing up it seemed like
most of the
best stories I heard from other kids were always sourced from some
kid's
bachelor uncle (half-way in age between the kid and the parent).
I have heard stories originating from any number of Uncle Bobs, Uncle
Georges,
Uncle Daves and Uncle Turks, but some of the most memorable came from
one
Uncle Donnie. This is only important in the context of the title
of this section, because as Uncle Donnie stories were always told they
would unravel, often incoherently if not nonsequetorially to a rousing
climax filled with awe, incomprehension shock and laughter. In
the
approaching lull after the climax, Uncle Donnie stories always
proceeded
and concluded with the phrase, "But that's not the weird part!"
The "weird part" of this topic
being
that after analyzing and some-what demystifying the "inevitability" of
small world encounters, to me the really intriguing part now is to
realize
how many small world events occur and go unrecognized by the parties
involved.
There must be a zillion cases where two people who know each other pass
unnoticed in a busy shop a thousand miles from home; or two strangers
pass
the time in a public place like a bus stop, never knowing that they
share
a common friend; or perhaps weirdest of all, two friends spend an
entire
lifetime without knowing they share a common friend or significant
event
in their past.
Having said all of this, there
are
still some small world stories that are just too mystical to
analyze.
A classic small world story comes from David, who I knew from graduate
school at Illinois. When David was in Junior High School on Long
Island, his parents sponsored a foreign exchange student from the
Philippines.
After they had picked up the high school girl from the airport and were
getting to know her the first night home, it came out that the girl's
mother
had attended university in the States; the University of Illinois to be
exact. This was greeted warmly, as both of David's parents are
Illinois
alumni. David's mother said that her freshman roommate had in
fact
been from the Philippines, and her name was Maria Gomez. The girl
smiled and said my mother's maiden name was Maria Gomez. David's
mother pulls out her freshman yearbook and the girl confirmed that it
was
indeed a picture of her mother. David's family called the
Philippines
that night and spoke to the mother/roommate. What are the odds?
Summary
The odds are not of one encounter happening at
a given
place at a given time. (very low)
The odds are than any encounter will ever happen
anywhere,
anytime. (very high)
Factors that increase the odds of any event
occurring.
1. subset of your
acquaintances is
much larger than you think;
2. can exclude a large number of
people you
will never know;
3. like people have like habits;
4. like people have like friends;
people tend to
notice
only people and things that are of interest to them.
5. location, itself, often
facilitates the
meeting;
magnet areas
draw lots
of people, primed for encounters
isolation forces
people
to have encounters
physical isolation - two people alone
cultural isolation - two people who have common differences from the
masses.
6. increased degrees of separation
(more
complexity) actually increase the chances
of the even
occurring.
There are four types of small world encounters.
1.
meeting of
acquaintance that you already know somewhere unexpectedly.
2. meeting a
stranger
who shares a common acquaintance with you.
3. having a
common life
experience with someone.
4. some complex
combination
of these three.
Parting Thoughts
Some of my small world
stories are
made somewhat more spectacular by the fact that my friends and I have
had
the good fortune to travel around the world some. However, this
is
not a prerequisite for a good small world story. In fact, by some
of the principles illustrated here, it is more likely that you will
cross
paths with other well traveled brethren in foreign lands, simply by the
nature of the participants and places they travel. A person who
spends
their life managing a Kwick-n-Go on a well-traveled road will
undoubtedly
have just as many small world story stories come to them. The
magic
in all of this is recognizing the small world encounter when it does
occur.
"I was singing my heart out
on the BBC,
when this little girl stopped me, I thought,
to ask for my autograph and tell me I was hot,
she said, 'I thought I recognized you.
You used to pump my gas back in old K.C.
Mizzou.'"
Robert Walkenhorst, 1991
return to home
|