GENERAL
What is Religion?
A belief system functioning within specific contexts
of rules and ceremonies.
Usually started by a male founder(s) who advocated following a certain
set of teachings, often proposing peaceful behavior of individuals toward
one another.
All religions provide answers to the reason for human existence (life)
and meaning for the unavoidable experience of the end to that existence
(death).
As part of their rules all religions have moral precepts, i.e., ways
to assure punishment for those perceived as mistreaters of their fellow
human beings and reward, or a better place in the next life, for individuals
who follow appropriate guidelines.
By now, most of the major religions are guided both by belief, say
in one God, and tradition, say in a certain approach to the founder's teaching
which is defended by a vast set of priests operating in bureaucracies.
BELIEF SYSTEMS
What are some specifics about several major religions?
In the West increased diversity since the Protestant
Reformation of the sixteenth century:
- Lutherans
- Anabaptists
- Anglicans
- Calvinists
- and many more were added to the Roman Catholic Church
- and Eastern Orthodox Churches, like the Russian, Greek
and Syrian.
And in other parts of the world other religions that we took
up in the first half of WC.
But one uniformity with all of them (even if at first Protestants,
too, wanted to get away from this supposedly restricting RCC phenomenon):
- a hierarchy;
- usually with the faithful at the bottom, then
the
brothers and sisters of the religious
orders, then
the deacons, etc. in the various Protestant
groups,
then the ministers and priests, then
the
bishops and metropolitans,
cardinals and patriarchs, and
the pope for the RCC;
- the faithful are usually talked to, or talked
at;
- women are excluded, except from the lowest ranks
of these hierarchies.
The faithful are encouraged in each institutional
setting to get close to God, but the setting discourages
such closeness:
- institutions tend not to be responsive to needs
of
individuals;
- institutions tend to have their own needs and
priorities which superimpose themselves
on those
of the faithful.
- Institutions design beliefs to suit their needs
and not the individual nor the "truths"
of their
faith;
- yet institutions help individuals fulfill their
various goals in life:
- by providing examples according to which the
individual faithful can arrange his/her
life,
- by designing customs and traditions which encourage
certain approved behaviors, and
- by setting appropriate ceremonies and regulations.
Because of the institutionalization of early
Christianity, we are still stuck with certain ways
of believing and doing that may not be in the
best interests of Christian believers.
Some examples:
- The resurrection of Christ: Gnostics, early
Christians whose records were repressed
by the Roman
Christians, did not believe that it
was a resurrection
in fact, that it was simply a reappearance
in the
minds of persons close to Christ.
- Because the early Roman Christian hierarchy needed
the
approbation of its first leaders having
been with the
resurrected Christ, by about 180AD that
certain kinds
of persons were perceived to have been
with Christ.
- Thus, Mary Magdalene, in spite of her closeness
to Jesus, was not included among the
apostles simply
because the hierarchy had increasingly
become male.
The last point indicates in part why
women were ex-
cluded from high positions in the Christian
churches.
Men had won the battle over the control
of churches.
OTHER MAJOR POINTS
- Humans discovered Gods when they recognized themselves
as different from nature and other species.
- Human beings made a further jump when they accepted
one war god as Lord and God.
- Fifteenth-century learning allowed investigations
of
the Old and New Testaments which has
not ceased yet:
e.g., we now know also of the Gnostic
Gospels.
- Protestantism allowed for a questioning of religious
authority which has not stopped; thus
we are quite
willing to say, in certain Protestant
groups, that
other Christians, like Roman Catholics,
are not quite
Christians.
- Since the eighteenth century, science and technology
have added a new dimension to religion.
-- At first scientists, including such
men as Isaac
Newton, who investigated
natural phenomena, tried
to explain nature
as a way of getting closer
to God.
-- By the late eighteenth century, technology
was
introduced, that is,
scientific activity for
practical purposes.
-- The latter, but also the radicalization
of science,
drew inventors, or
discoverers, away from
explaining nature
to controlling nature.
-- Knowing nature, as we know from classroom
science
experiments, is controlling
nature.
-- Explaining nature also can mean the
opening of a
door to the unkown,
even the loss of control.
-- Explaining nature in some ways also
means
explaining God, and
the end of God as an
independent phenomenon
but as a belief
in ourselves.
Explaining God is quite obviously not the same as
believing in God.
- We cannot know God, except through our own frail
mental efforts.
- But we can explain God's historical emergence
in the
species' mind, that is, we can realize
God's existence
only through belief or through the emergence
of the
phenomenon in our heads.
- Whatever we believe Jesus to have been, even his
own
explanation of being the son of God
is not fully
satisfying because he had to use contemporary
images
to convey meanings.
- But however we look at the issue, just by trying
to explain in a rational fashion, we
move beyond being
part of nature to explaining nature
and thus
breaking the bond with it.